Affiliate Marketing & Fraud: Separated At Birth?

What is it about the Internet that brings out the worst in people?  Is it because there is so much money to be made online, and it infuriates the people that aren’t making it?  Or is it just because the anonymity provided by the computer and the distance between users that allows them to behave in outrageous ways that they never would in person?

There a lot of people that make a good living by effectively marketing a product or service to a targeted audience through many different methods including PPC, SEO, Email, PPV, and Social Media.  However, I would venture to say that there are way, way, way more people out there that are working just as hard even harder to make money by scamming & cheating their way along.

Just look at the majority of users on the Black Hat World forums, for example.  There is thread after thread on that board about how to make illegitimate monies online.  Don’t get me wrong, there is nothing wrong with automation or campaign optimization tools that make our jobs as marketers easier.  I’m all for those.  Every industry has its tools of the trade.  What irks me is when it goes farther than that.

Case in point: Packet Stuffer.  This is a tool that was designed to steal commissions from legitimate affiliates and give it to people lazy and stupid enough to use it.  I’m sure there are plenty of angles that could be argued in favor of a tool like this, but it rubs me the wrong way.  When you have spent a bunch of time building the perfect landing page, optimizing your ad copy, spending money on PPC until you get the campaign profitable and finally get back into the black, the last thing that you need is some idiot siphoning off your commissions.  It doesn’t matter if it’s only one here and there, every lead counts and can have a huge effect on the EPC of your campaign and whether or not it makes sense to keep it going.

So please, if you are a new affiliate (or even an experienced affiliate) that is tempted by the dark side of the industry and the allure of getting something for nothing, just remember the old adage: if it seems too good to be true, it probably is.  You will not make tons of money.  You will have your affiliate accounts terminated at all of the networks that you work with, and you will have wasted your time and money.  Furthermore, you are only helping to paint the entire Affiliate Marketing industry in the type of negative light that doesn’t do any of us any favors.  If you want this industry to become more accepted in the mainstream and continue to see growth over the next decade, you need to start treating it like you would any other job: with respect.

I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, it’s not that hard to be a legitimate affiliate, just do some actual marketing and you’re all set.

Fun With Frauders: AIM Style

The following is a transcription from a recent affiliate applicant to my network, TriFoxMedia (I believe he was referred from Digital Point):

hualiwei: Hello
hualiwei: Nice to meet you..
trifoxmedia: hello
hualiwei: Please review and approval of my account
hualiwei: 😉
trifoxmedia: are you fraud?
hualiwei: NO
trifoxmedia: quality traffic?
hualiwei: Absolutely not right. .
trifoxmedia: great!
trifoxmedia: first and last name of account?
hualiwei: 😛
hualiwei: Huali Wei
trifoxmedia: great, i’ll look at your application
hualiwei: ok,thank you.
hualiwei: Immediately over the weekend, and where to leave ah?
trifoxmedia: come again?
hualiwei: sorry..
hualiwei:  My English is not very good.
hualiwei:  Language you would it?
hualiwei: You are busy with work, I am still waiting for your news quiet is better, otherwise you will think that my trouble
hualiwei: 😛
trifoxmedia: i couldnt understand your last question
hualiwei:  When I think about how to say better.
hualiwei: Where to go Sunday Holiday
hualiwei: That this will get it?
trifoxmedia: congratulations! You are approved for denial.

hualiwei: Hello
hualiwei: Nice to meet you..
TFXBoone: hello
hualiwei: Please review and approval of my account
hualiwei: 😉
TFXBoone: are you fraud?
hualiwei: NO
TFXBoone: quality traffic?
hualiwei: Absolutely not right. .
TFXBoone: great!
TFXBoone: 🙂
TFXBoone: first and last name of account?
hualiwei: 😛
hualiwei: Huali Wei
TFXBoone: great, i’ll look at your application
hualiwei: ok,thank you.
hualiwei: Immediately over the weekend, and where to leave ah?
TFXBoone: come again?
hualiwei: sorry..
hualiwei:  My English is not very good.
TFXBoone: that’s ok!
hualiwei:  Language you would it?
hualiwei: You are busy with work, I am still waiting for your news quiet is better, otherwise you will think that my trouble
hualiwei: 😛
TFXBoone: well i couldnt understand your last question
hualiwei:  When I think about how to say better. .
hualiwei: Where to go Sunday Holiday
hualiwei: That this will get it?;-)
TFXBoone: congratulations! You are approved for denial.

Fraud Alert: Email/Zip Submit Freelancers

We had a surge of bad leads on Email & Zip Submit offers on my network in August, so I’ve been digging into where this traffic is coming from.  The thing that was puzzling me is that some of the fraud leads were coming from established affiliates that we know and have done business with for a long time.  Weird, right?

Upon further examination & questioning, the truth came out.  My affiliates were suckered into hiring freelancers that promised that they could “get lots of email & zip submit leads” for them.  Of course all the freelancers were doing is submitting fake email addresses & zip codes into these offers on a massive scale.  I’m assuming that they were paid up front for their services, so they don’t care what happens to the affiliate once the advertiser discovers the bad leads.

So… If you are cruising eLance or BlackHatWorld and find someone selling their “excellent” email & zip submit marketing services to you, don’t fall for it.  If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

Long story short, here’s what will happen: you will not be paid for the fake leads, you will most likely be terminated from your affiliate network, you will scar your reputation in the industry so it will be harder to get into other networks, and you will be out the money that you paid to the freelance scammer.  There are plenty of legitimate ways to promote email & zip submit offers, if you need help just ask your affiliate manager or listen to my podcast with Andrew Wee where I discuss a promotion method.

Stay classy San Diego.

Stop Cheating Yourself Out Of Money

Lately I have been seeing way too many affiliates getting shut down for fraud.  They are always finding new ways to exploit the system to make a quick buck, then praying that they don’t get caught by the affiliate network, the advertiser, the search engines, etc.

This is so stupid!  I know full well that to be the best affiliate marketer you can be, you constantly need to be testing the limits.  Pushing into the grey areas is often where we find the most profitable new techniques to market our wares.  The problem is, a lot of affiliates forget where the line is, and once crossed they never return.  There may be a rush of feeling like you’ve cheated the system and made money so easily that it should be illegal, and in most cases, it is!

What bothers me the most about this is that I have seen so many extremely talented programmers & marketers get paid absolutely nothing for their efforts, not to mention the risk of litigation and/or jail time.  I can’t help but think that if these individuals put their skills to work on the numerous legal and above-the-board marketing methods, they could be rolling in the dough right now.

If any of this is sounding familiar to you, do yourself a favor and cut out the crap.  It doesn’t take a genious to cloak Craigslist traffic and trick people into signing up for offers.  It also doesn’t take a genius to iframe an email submit box onto a page, obscuring everything but the submit button.  Even if you fool everyone on the front end, there is still the advertiser’s back end, which is where most of these schemes are hung out to dry.  It is very easy for an advertiser to tell who is sending junk traffic and who is not, and the second they alert your affiliate network, say goodbye to those commissions.

A side note to the scammers are the people that put so much time and energy into marketing online offers offline.  This is the most counter-intuitive thing I have ever heard of.  The internet presents the most flexible, trackable, and profitable means of marketing ever devised.  Why is it that so many new affiliates think it would be such a great idea to go back to the dark ages of using paper flyers or telesales to get people to their landing pages?  The printing press was invented in 1439.  Get over it.  Besides, you are killing trees with your stupid spam flyers.  There is no physical way possible to generate the amount of traffic to affiliate offers through these archaic methods as there is through search engines, email marketing, media buying, PPV, and all the other online methods.  You think you can hand out enough flyers on a college campus to drive 1,000 ringtones leads in one day?  Even if it were possible, what about the next day?  What about at 3 AM when you should be sleeping?  Are your flyers out there handing themselves out?  I didn’t think so.

Like I said, it’s not that hard to figure out how to do this the right way, and the other opportunities that present themselves simply by being good at what you do are limitless.  There is no telling what is on the horizon in this industry, and companies are always looking for marketers on the cutting edge.  Just make sure it’s the right edge.